Attorney Testimonials
For over two decades, Dr. Shaul Gabbay has been a trusted expert witness in immigration and asylum cases, providing in-depth cultural analysis and testimony that strengthens legal arguments.
Attorneys rely on his deep understanding of Muslim-majority countries, honor-based societies, and political conditions to present clear, credible, and persuasive cases.
"Dr. Gabbay’s testimony in our case was invaluable. The judge specifically cited his detailed analysis and well-documented report as a key factor in the decision to grant asylum.
His expertise on the political and cultural dynamics of the region and his ability to present the facts clearly and convincingly were critical. I have already recommended him to my colleagues and will continue to do so without reservation."
G. Eric Sproull, Immigration Attorney
"Dr. Gabbay didn’t just hit a home run; he knocked it out of the park! I have never seen a judge as impressed with an expert witness as this judge was with Dr. Gabbay.
His demeanor, style, and inexhaustible knowledge of the politics, culture, and social traditions of the country put the judge over the top. But for Prof. Gabbay, my client’s family would be mourning his death; instead, they are celebrating his life."
Robert M. Birach, Esq., Michigan Chapter, AILA Chairman
"Dr. Gabbay’s research and expert testimony are exceptional. His clear and convincing explanations were instrumental in securing relief for my client.
I commend him to any attorney handling cases where issues relating to Islam or the Muslim world are central to the claim."
Jack Herzig, Esquire, Law Offices of Jack Herzig, Wyncote, Pennsylvania
"Dr. Gabbay not only helped win my case but saved my client’s life.
He is well-prepared, very professional, objective, and unimpeachable."
Justin W. Chaney, Esq., Immigration Attorney, Atlanta, Georgia
"Dr. Gabbay provided a professional and thorough analysis for my client’s appeal. His detailed and clear testimony played an instrumental role in securing a positive outcome.
I just received word from the USCIS supervisor that the appeal was granted and that my client will be scheduled for their oath ceremony soon. Many thanks to Dr. Gabbay for his invaluable support."
Leslie Karam, Attorney, Karam Law, Bloomington, Minnesota
"Dr. Gabbay’s report was extremely helpful, and I would go so far as to say that his analysis won the case for us. His ability to convey the complexities of the region and connect them to our client’s specific situation was unparalleled."
Kathleen “Kathy” Lambert, Attorney, Stephenson, Chavarri & Lambert, LLC
"My client from Yemen was granted asylum thanks to Dr. Gabbay. His smooth and persuasive testimony left no room for doubt, even during cross-examination.
His presence in the courtroom eased tensions, and the judge readily accepted him as an expert without hesitation."
David L. Cleveland, Attorney, Catholic Charities of Washington, DC
"Dr. Gabbay’s expert testimony is always credible, persuasive, and non-refutable. I have never lost a single case where Dr. Gabbay served as an expert witness."
Ally Bolour, Attorney at Law, Los Angeles, California
"Dr. Gabbay’s extensive knowledge of political, social, and religious issues in the Middle East is unparalleled. His testimony is clear, convincing, and respectful, earning the trust and admiration of judges and attorneys alike.
I would never go to court without his expert testimony, which he delivers with modesty and confidence. He is truly a great asset to our profession and clients."
Mazen M. Sukkar, Attorney, Sukkar & Associates, Florida
"Professor Gabbay’s testimony was crucial in winning the case. The judge cited his expertise repeatedly in her decision to grant our client relief, describing the dangers he would face if deported to Pakistan.
His testimony was so compelling that the judge deemed additional witnesses unnecessary. We are deeply grateful for his contributions."
Garfield Heslop, Managing Partner, Heslop & Kalba LLP, Brooklyn, New York
"Dr. Gabbay’s expertise is second to none. His ability to articulate the dangers my client faced upon return to their home country made a decisive difference.
Without his report and testimony, the outcome would have been very different. I highly recommend Dr. Gabbay as an expert witness for cases involving the Muslim world."
Samira Recob, Esq., Law Office of Samira Recob, Westminster, Colorado
"Dr. Gabbay’s written report and oral testimony were key to success in a challenging asylum case. The immigration judge stated that his testimony tipped the balance in favor of my client."
Shannon M. Jackson, Attorney at Law, Chicago, Illinois
"Thank you for your assistance in my Iranian case. Your affidavit and testimony carried great weight in the approval of my client’s relief application.
Your informed responses during cross-examination only further validated our claims. I look forward to working with you on future cases."
Naima Said, Attorney at Law, Columbia, Maryland
"Our clients, a family of three from Afghanistan, faced grave threats and an uncertain future. Professor Gabbay’s extensive and well-researched report detailed the risks they would face if returned, serving as a potent weapon in our fight to save their lives.
Based on his report, the family was granted residence in The Netherlands. We will always be grateful for Professor Gabbay’s work and his dedicated team’s support."
M. van Zantvoort, Collet International Lawyers, and Dr. Joost Brouwer, Refugee Support Group, Hartekreten, Netherlands
"Our law firm has retained the services of Professor Gabbay in at least five challenging asylum, withholding of removal, and Convention Against Torture cases arising from Muslim countries. I have no hesitation in pointing to his written affidavits and in-court testimony as the primary reason for our success in each of these cases.
The first time we retained his services, in a CAT case from Iran, we knew his credentials but didn’t know his written work or in-court demeanor. His affidavit in that case—as in all of the cases since—was impressive, synthesizing the country’s political and social history, current events, and treatment of perceived dissidents with our client’s specific facts.
Prof. Gabbay’s detailed, fluid, and thoughtful in-court testimony elaborated with ease on points of concern in the CAT claim. Needless to say, we have sought Prof. Gabbay’s services in cases from Sudan, Somalia, and Iraq with the same thoroughness, care, and intellect. Without a doubt, his expertise is the reason we prevailed in each of these cases."
Jesse Evans-Schroeder
Partner/Director of Immigration Litigation
Green Evans-Schroeder, PLLC
"Dr. Gabbay’s depth of knowledge about the Islamic world and his ability to contextualize it for each individual case are unparalleled.
He consistently saves lives through his work, and it is an honor to collaborate with such a dedicated expert."
Lama Alwan-Northcutt, Attorney at Law, Law Offices of Jonathan A. Bartell
"The value of Dr. Gabbay’s testimony in asylum cases cannot be overstated. His knowledgeable and persuasive testimony brings my clients’ experiences to life in a way that the court can truly understand.
Without his input, the extent of my clients’ asylum claims might have been overlooked. Thank you for your invaluable contributions.”
Elizabeth H. Ryser, Attorney at Law, Westlake, Ohio
"Dr. Gabbay’s expert report and testimony were pivotal in demonstrating the dangers my client faced. The judge specifically noted that Dr. Gabbay’s testimony tipped the balance in our favor.
His professionalism and thorough preparation make him a standout expert witness."
Desireé C. Hernández, Esq., Law Offices of Jan Allen Reiner
"Professor Gabbay’s report and testimony transformed my client’s case. His ability to navigate complex issues and provide expert clarity resulted in a favorable decision for our client.
I will continue to use his services at every opportunity."
Gary Silbiger, Co-Founder, National Immigration Project of the National Lawyers Guild
"Dr. Gabbay’s expert analysis of Islamic extremism in Pakistan was pivotal. The Immigration Judge specifically cited his testimony in granting withholding of removal, describing it as the key difference in the case. He has earned my highest recommendation."
Shannon M. Jackson, Attorney at Law, Chicago, Illinois
"Your detailed and comprehensive analysis of Middle Eastern conditions was essential in my client’s asylum case. The immigration judge was finally able to understand the nuances of the situation thanks to your expertise."
Farshad Owji, Attorney at Law, San Francisco, California
"Professor Gabbay’s professional and well-researched report gave an excellent picture of the dangers my client faced. His in-person testimony further updated and clarified the written report, securing a favorable decision for my client."
Ron Oldenburg, Attorney at Law, Hawaii
"Dr. Gabbay’s expert testimony and written report were outstanding in a challenging withholding of removal case. His ability to accommodate a complex, remanded case was impressive, and I highly recommend him."
Sara Dady, Attorney, Dady Law Office, Rockford, Illinois
"Thank you for your patience and expert testimony in my client’s withholding of removal case. The judge cited your insights as a significant factor in their decision."
Howard R. Brill, Attorney at Law, Hempstead, New York
"Dr. Gabbay’s professionalism and expertise in an Iranian CAT claim were remarkable. Both the immigration judge and ICE counsel found his testimony and report highly persuasive.
I have already recommended him to other attorneys and would gladly work with him again."
Leo Jerome Lahey, Attorney at Law, New Orleans, Louisiana
"Dr. Gabbay’s research and court testimony in an Iranian apostasy case were impeccable. His insights guided all parties toward a fuller understanding, leading to a favorable outcome for my client. I will rely on his expertise for future cases."
Jonathan Willmoth, Attorney, Willmoth Immigration Law, Kansas City, Missouri
"Dr. Gabbay’s comprehensive testimony was the overriding factor in the success of my client’s CAT application. Our firm intends to retain him for future cases involving Muslim and Middle Eastern countries."
Kenneth S. Levine, Esq., Levine & Eskandari, LLC, Atlanta, Georgia
“Dr. Gabbay is the first expert I call for cases involving clients from the Muslim world. In a very difficult case, his written report and oral testimony remained calm, authoritative, and highly effective in the face of a hostile immigration judge.”
Patricia S. Mann, Attorney at Law, New York, New York
"Dr. Gabbay’s testimony was pivotal in a complex CAT merits hearing. The immigration judge specifically noted that his research and testimony tipped the balance in favor of my client. I will unreservedly use his services again in future cases."
Mac Nayeri, Attorney at Law, Guadalupe, Arizona
"Dr. Gabbay’s expertise is evident in both his written reports and oral testimony. In a case involving a client from Jordan, his testimony convinced the judge of the dangers faced by the client if deported.”
Brian L. Aust, Attorney at Law, St. Paul, Minnesota
"Professor Gabbay’s report clearly explained the dangers faced by political opposition members and religious converts in Iran. The asylum officer relied heavily on his analysis, granting asylum to my client and his wife."
Dree K. Collopy, Attorney at Law, Maggio & Kattar, P.C., Washington, DC
"Dr. Gabbay’s testimony in an Egyptian apostasy case was truly remarkable. His superlative professionalism, detailed analysis, and fair conclusions impressed both the court and myself."
Ramsin Sheeno, Attorney at Law, Sherman Oaks, California
"I won a Moroccan gay asylum case based on a well-founded fear of persecution. Dr. Gabbay’s excellent affidavit was instrumental in the success of this case.
He was prepared to testify telephonically, but the trial attorney found his affidavit so compelling that no further testimony was needed."
Steven M. Klapisch, Attorney at Law, Weisberg Friedman & Klapisch, LLP, New York, NY
"Dr. Gabbay provided a credible and persuasive report on the dangers faced by a Jehovah’s Witness convert from Islam in Jordan. His testimony—delivered telephonically—was just as impactful as if it had been in person."
John W. Craig, Attorney at Law, Los Angeles, California
"Dr. Gabbay provided an outstanding report for my HIV+ Pakistani client’s asylum case. His thorough affidavit was critical to our success, and I would gladly use his services again."
Victoria Neilson, Legal Director, Immigration Equality, New York, NY
"Dr. Gabbay’s expert analysis of Islamic extremism in Pakistan was pivotal. The Immigration Judge specifically cited his testimony in granting withholding of removal, describing it as the key difference in the case."
Daniel Shanfield, Attorney at Law, San Jose, California
"Dr. Gabbay’s deep understanding of Muslim and Middle Eastern societies adds invaluable context to immigration cases. One of my clients, a Palestinian from Gaza, was granted asylum thanks to his expert report and testimony."
Rachel Effron, Attorney at Law, The Effron Law Firm, LLC, Atlanta, Georgia
"Dr. Gabbay is a consummate scholar and passionate expert in Middle Eastern and Muslim issues. His impeccable credentials, personal experience, and articulate testimony make him a standout witness.
I have worked with him on cases involving various countries, from Palestine to Syria, and his input has been instrumental in securing justice for my clients."
Svetlana J. Schreiber, Attorney, Cleveland, Ohio
"Dr. Gabbay’s comprehensive report and expert court testimony were vital to my client’s successful asylum claim. His insight and thorough analysis convinced the judge to grant asylum. I would gladly use his services again and highly recommend him to others."
Michael Hafkin, Attorney, Clayman, Tapper & Baram, LLC
"Dr. Gabbay provided clear, concise, and compelling testimony in a sexual orientation-based asylum case. He anticipated and effectively addressed challenges during cross-examination, earning praise from the immigration judge."
Kevin W. Jones, Esq., Jones Casado LLP, New York, NY
"Dr. Gabbay provided invaluable testimony for my client, a convert from Islam to Christianity seeking asylum in Pakistan. He addressed critical issues raised by the government, and his testimony was key to securing asylum for my client and her family.
I believe the case would not have been won without his expertise."
Deborah Lee, Attorney at Law, Margaret W. Wong & Associates, Cleveland, Ohio
"When I first spoke with Professor Gabbay, I knew I had found the perfect expert witness for my challenging case. His ability to grasp complex issues, navigate subtleties, and present exceptional written and testimonial evidence added significant credibility to our case.
He worked under tight deadlines and was always accessible, even while traveling abroad. I would readily rely on Professor Gabbay’s expertise again."
Amber Montano, Attorney at Law, San Francisco, California
"Professor Gabbay’s expert testimony regarding country conditions in Iran was instrumental in winning my client’s case. His in-depth knowledge and ability to convey the dangers faced by my client were exceptional.
I would not hesitate to work with him again."
Roni P. Deutsch, Attorney at Law, Encino, California